Western (American) Evangelicalism

I am frequently tempted to describe it as a kind of “Christian Bhakti,” a pure ecstatic devotionalism, as opposed to those more “Vedic” forms of Christianity that ground themselves in ancient traditions. Much of American Evangelicalism not only lacks any sense of tradition, but is blithely hostile to tradition on principle: What is tradition, after all, other than man-made history, and what is history other than exile from paradise? What need does one have of tradition when one has the Bible, that eternal love letter from Jesus to the soul, inerrant, unambiguous, uncorrupted by the vicissitudes of human affairs? In some of its most extreme forms, Evangelicalism is a religion of total and unsullied reverie, the pure present of the child’s world, where ingenuous outcries and happy gestures and urgent conjurations instantly bring forth succor and substance. And, at its most intensely fundamentalist, so precipitous is its flight from the gravity of history into Edenic and eschatological rapture that it reduces all of cosmic history to a few thousand years of terrestrial existence and the whole of the present to a collection of signs urgently pointing to the world’s imminent ending.

David Bentley Hart, Source: David Bentley Hart on American Religion

I Am Not Afraid

Malis flinched at the explosion. The sound of thunder, loud enough to shake her steel front door, came not from the sky, but from beyond the neighboring buildings. She stretched her neck to look over the rooftops and trees for the light of fire. Nothing.

“That’s good…” she thought. All day long, these falling គ្រាប់កាំភ្លើងធំ, or bullets of the big guns, pounded the world around her, from the north, then the east, and the west, causing her heart to shake in her chest. What was their target?

“Not my house. I am not afraid.” She entered and paced around her home. It was evening and she hoped she would get some sleep tonight. Another blast, then darkness. The power went out. Malis stood in the black, waiting.

“The lights will come back soon.” Thirty minutes passed. No power. It grew hot in the house. Malis went back outside. More darkness.

“I will call my husband…”

“What? No signal?”

Malis walked out into the street. Quiet, shadows heavy and still.

“Oh, Makara’s house still has light. I will walk there.”

Approaching Makara’s house, she did not hear the sound of a generator, which Makara’s foreign husband would have turned on soon after the lights went out. Only a single solar-powered light shone there. It was quiet and ghostly. The house was shuttered up. The cold white light was not comforting. Malis crouched down in front of the house and tried her phone again. Still no signal.

“Malis?”

“Yes?” It was Chantrea, the woman who lived on the other side of Makara’s home. She walked toward Malis. Chantrea’s ten year old boy, Dany, was with her.

“Come,” Chantrea said, “It’s time to go. We need to leave Poipet. I have my truck. We are leaving.”

“Going where?”

“To Battambang. Come. Pack a bag and put it in my truck.”

“I cannot leave. I don’t know where my husband is.” She held up her phone. “I cannot call him.”

“My phone doesn’t work either. You can call your husband when we have left the city. Come. I don’t want to drive with just my kids.”

“No. I will stay. I am not afraid.”

“No! You come!” Dany grabbed onto Malis’s arm, startling her. “My mom will drive us to Battambang!”

“No, no,” Malis smiled warmly at the boy, “I will stay. Don’t worry about me.”

“Well, think about changing your mind. We are going to get ready to go,” Chantrea said, and pulled Dany away.

For some time after Chantrea’s tail lights faded into the dark, Malis stayed crouched in front of Makara’s house. She didn’t yet know it would be two more days before the power and phone signals came back. Another loud blast pushed her up and back to her home.

***

ម៉ាលីសភ្ញាក់ព្រើតដោយសារសំឡេងផ្ទុះដ៏ខ្លាំងមួយ។ សំឡេងដូចផ្គរលាន់ ដែលខ្លាំងរហូតដល់ធ្វើឱ្យទ្វារដែកខាងមុខផ្ទះរបស់នាងញ័រ មិនមែនមកពីលើមេឃទេ ប៉ុន្តែមកពីតំបន់ខាងក្រោយអគារដែលនៅជិតៗនោះ។ នាងលូកកមើលរំលងដំបូលផ្ទះ និងដើមឈើ ដើម្បីរកមើលពន្លឺភ្លើងដែលអាចបណ្តាលមកពីការផ្ទុះ។ ប៉ុន្តែគ្មានអ្វីសោះ។

«ល្អហើយ…» នាងគិតក្នុងចិត្ត។

ពេញមួយថ្ងៃ គ្រាប់កាំភ្លើងធំទាំងនេះបានបាញ់ធ្លាក់មកលើតំបន់ជុំវិញនាងឥតឈប់ឈរ។ ម្តងមកពីទិសខាងជើង បន្ទាប់មកពីទិសខាងកើត ហើយក្រោយមកទៀតពីទិសខាងលិច ធ្វើឱ្យបេះដូងនាងញ័រដូចជាចង់លោតចេញពីទ្រូង។ តើពួកគេកំពុងបាញ់សំដៅទៅរកគោលដៅអ្វី?

«កុំឱ្យត្រូវផ្ទះខ្ញុំទៅបានហើយ។ ខ្ញុំមិនខ្លាចទេ»។

នាងចូលទៅក្នុងផ្ទះ ហើយដើរចុះដើរឡើង។ ពេលនេះជាពេលល្ងាចហើយ ហើយនាងសង្ឃឹមថាយប់នេះនឹងអាចគេងលក់បានខ្លះ។ ស្រាប់តែមានសំឡេងផ្ទុះមួយទៀត បន្ទាប់មកអ្វីៗក៏ងងឹតសូន្យ។ ភ្លើងអគ្គិសនីបានដាច់។ ម៉ាលីសឈរនៅក្នុងភាពងងឹត ដោយរង់ចាំ។

«បន្តិចទៀតភ្លើងនឹងមកវិញហើយ»។

សាមសិបនាទីបានកន្លងផុតទៅ។ នៅតែគ្មានភ្លើង។ ខាងក្នុងផ្ទះកាន់តែក្តៅឡើងៗ។ ម៉ាលីសក៏ចេញទៅខាងក្រៅវិញ។ នៅតែងងឹតដដែល។

«ខ្ញុំនឹងទូរស័ព្ទទៅប្តីខ្ញុំ…»

«អីយ៉ា? គ្មានសេវាទូរស័ព្ទទៀត?»

ម៉ាលីសដើរចេញទៅតាមផ្លូវ។ គ្រប់យ៉ាងស្ងាត់ជ្រងំ ស្រមោលងងឹតគ្របដណ្តប់ជុំវិញ ហើយគ្មានអ្វីកម្រើកសោះ។

«អូ ផ្ទះម៉ាការ៉ានៅមានភ្លើង។ ខ្ញុំនឹងដើរទៅទីនោះ»។

ពេលដើរទៅជិតផ្ទះម៉ាការ៉ា នាងមិនឮសំឡេងម៉ាស៊ីនភ្លើងទេ។ ជាធម្មតា ប្តីជនបរទេសរបស់ម៉ាការ៉ានឹងបើកម៉ាស៊ីនភ្លើងភ្លាមៗ បន្ទាប់ពីភ្លើងអគ្គិសនីដាច់។ មានតែអំពូលមួយដែលប្រើថាមពលពន្លឺព្រះអាទិត្យប៉ុណ្ណោះ ដែលកំពុងបញ្ចេញពន្លឺនៅទីនោះ។ ទីនោះស្ងាត់ស្ងៀម និងស្រពិចស្រពិលដូចជាផ្ទះខ្មោច។ បង្អួច និងទ្វារផ្ទះត្រូវបានបិទជិត។ ពន្លឺពណ៌សត្រជាក់នោះមិនអាចធ្វើឱ្យនាងមានអារម្មណ៍កក់ក្តៅចិត្តបានឡើយ។

ម៉ាលីសអង្គុយច្រកោងនៅមុខផ្ទះ ហើយព្យាយាមប្រើទូរស័ព្ទម្តងទៀត។ នៅតែគ្មានសេវាដដែល។

«ម៉ាលីស?»

«ចាស?»

នោះគឺចន្ទ្រា ជាស្ត្រីដែលរស់នៅម្ខាងទៀតនៃផ្ទះម៉ាការ៉ា។ នាងដើរឆ្ពោះមករកម៉ាលីស។ កូនប្រុសអាយុដប់ឆ្នាំរបស់ចន្ទ្រា ឈ្មោះដានី ក៏នៅជាមួយនាងដែរ។

«មក!» ចន្ទ្រានិយាយ។ «ដល់ពេលចេញទៅហើយ។ យើងត្រូវចាកចេញពីប៉ោយប៉ែត។ ខ្ញុំមានឡានភីកអាប់។ យើងនឹងចេញដំណើរឥឡូវនេះ»។

«ទៅណា?»

«ទៅបាត់ដំបង។ មក! រៀបចំខោអាវដាក់កាបូបមួយ ហើយយកទៅដាក់ក្នុងឡានខ្ញុំ»។

«ខ្ញុំចាកចេញមិនបានទេ។ ខ្ញុំមិនដឹងថាប្តីខ្ញុំនៅឯណាផង»។ នាងលើកទូរស័ព្ទរបស់នាងឡើង។ «ខ្ញុំទាក់ទងទៅគាត់មិនបានទេ»។

«ទូរស័ព្ទខ្ញុំក៏ប្រើមិនបានដែរ។ ពេលយើងចេញផុតពីទីក្រុងហើយ អ្នកអាចទូរស័ព្ទទៅប្តីអ្នកបាន។ មកជាមួយខ្ញុំទៅ។ ខ្ញុំមិនចង់បើកឡានធ្វើដំណើរជាមួយតែកូនៗខ្ញុំពីរបីនាក់ទេ»។

«អត់ទេ។ ខ្ញុំនឹងនៅទីនេះ។ ខ្ញុំមិនខ្លាចទេ»។

«អត់ទេ! អ្នកត្រូវមកជាមួយយើង!»

ដានីបានចាប់ដៃម៉ាលីសជាប់ ធ្វើឱ្យនាងភ្ញាក់ផ្អើល។

«ម៉ាក់ខ្ញុំនឹងបើកឡានយើងទៅបាត់ដំបង!» ក្មេងប្រុសនោះនិយាយ។

«អត់ទេ អត់ទេ» ម៉ាលីសញញឹមយ៉ាងកក់ក្តៅទៅកាន់ក្មេងប្រុសនោះ។ «ខ្ញុំនឹងនៅទីនេះ។ កុំបារម្ភពីខ្ញុំអី»។

«អ៊ីចឹង អ្នកគិតម្តងទៀតទៅ ប្រសិនបើអ្នកចង់ប្តូរចិត្ត។ យើងនឹងទៅរៀបចំខ្លួនចេញដំណើរហើយ» ចន្ទ្រានិយាយ រួចទាញដានីឱ្យដើរទៅជាមួយនាង។

មួយសន្ទុះធំ បន្ទាប់ពីភ្លើងខាងក្រោយឡានរបស់ចន្ទ្រាបានរលត់បាត់ទៅក្នុងភាពងងឹត ម៉ាលីសនៅតែអង្គុយច្រកោងនៅមុខផ្ទះម៉ាការ៉ា។

នៅពេលនោះ នាងមិនទាន់ដឹងទេថា នឹងត្រូវរង់ចាំពីរថ្ងៃទៀត ទើបភ្លើងអគ្គិសនី និងសេវាទូរស័ព្ទត្រឡប់មកវិញ។

សំឡេងផ្ទុះដ៏ខ្លាំងមួយទៀតបានបន្លឺឡើង ធ្វើឱ្យនាងស្ទុះក្រោក ហើយប្រញាប់ត្រឡប់ទៅផ្ទះរបស់នាងវិញ។

Will Alberta Separate from Canada?

Right now there is a strong separatist movement within Alberta. Many Albertans are dissatisfied with how the province is being treated by the federal government. This is not a new issue. It has been going on for decades. However, it is more serious now than before.

Will Alberta actually separate? My guess is almost certainly not, at least not in this generation.

Separation is not easy, and it needs a strong majority of more than just Albertans to happen.

What is necessary to trigger a referendum within Alberta?

🗳 1. Start With a Citizen Initiative Petition

To trigger a referendum in Alberta, citizens don’t just vote on it — they must organize a formal petition process under the Citizen Initiative Act. That process goes like this:

✅ a) File a Notice of Intent

  • An eligible elector (a Canadian citizen age 18+, resident of Alberta) must file a notice of intent with the Chief Electoral Officer of Alberta.
  • They must pay an application fee (currently $25,000 for a referendum application), which may be refundable if the petition succeeds.

✅ b) Submit a Formal Application

  • Within 30 days after filing the notice of intent, the proponent submits a full application for the initiative petition.
  • If the application meets requirements, the Chief Electoral Officer issues the petition officially.

📊 2. Collect Enough Signatures to Meet the Threshold

Once the petition is issued, supporters must collect valid signatures from eligible electors in a set period. For different types of issues, the thresholds differ:

🔹 Constitutional Referendum Proposal

(Which is how separation would be classified under Alberta law)

  • Supporters must collect signatures from 10 % of the number of Albertans who voted in the most recent provincial general election.
  • That 10 % is based on actual ballots cast — which currently works out to around ~177,000 signatures.
  • Signatures must be collected within a specified period (typically up to 120 days).

(Note: earlier versions of the law required 20 % of all registered electors and signatures in 2/3 of divisions, but recent amendments lowered and simplified the threshold.)


📅 3. Verification and Referendum Call

If organizers successfully collect and submit the required number of valid signatures:

  • Elections Alberta verifies the signatures and confirms whether the threshold is met.
  • Once verified, the provincial government is legally required to hold a referendum on the proposed question.
  • That referendum must happen on or before the fixed date of the next general provincial election (or, if too soon, the election after that).

🧠 What Happens Next

A successful petition doesn’t immediately result in separation — it forces the referendum on the ballot with the specific question you asked (e.g., “Should Alberta cease to be part of Canada?”). The actual legal effect of that referendum, especially for something as consequential as secession, depends on federal constitutional law, not just provincial processes.


📌 Simple Breakdown — What’s Necessary in Alberta to Trigger a Referendum

  1. An eligible Albertan files a notice of intent to start a citizen initiative petition with Elections Alberta.
  2. Submit a full application for a referendum petition within 30 days and pay the application fee.
  3. Collect the required signatures (about 10 % of voters from the last election — about 177 000).
  4. Elections Alberta verifies the petition.
  5. The provincial government must then hold the referendum on the next election ballot.

If the referendum is successful, what happens next?

🧾 1. There Is No Right to Unilaterally Secede

Under the Canadian Constitution, a province cannot legally leave Canada on its own. The Supreme Court of Canada ruled in the Reference re Secession of Quebec (1998) that:

  • A province does not have a constitutional or international law right to unilaterally secede from Canada.
  • Any attempt to secede must be done through a constitutional amendment and negotiations with the federal government and other provinces.
  • Even a referendum with a majority vote doesn’t automatically trigger separation; it would trigger a duty to negotiate that could lead to separation if terms are agreed.

🗳 2. Referendum Requirements (Clarity Act)

Canada’s Clarity Act (2000), passed in response to that Supreme Court decision, sets out how a province could initiate the process in a way the federal government will deal with it:

✔️ Clear Question — A referendum question must be unambiguous about secession.
✔️ Clear Majority — The outcome must show a clear majority in favour of secession (not just a bare 50 %+1; what counts as “clear” is decided by the House of Commons).
✔️ Negotiation Trigger — Only after a clear result on a clear question would Canada be obliged to enter negotiations on terms of separation.
✔️ Federal Approval to Negotiate — Before any negotiations start, the House of Commons must agree the referendum was clear and valid.
✔️ Constitutional Amendment Needed — The only legal path to actual secession is via a constitutional amendment negotiated and agreed to under Part V of the Constitution Act, 1982.

So even if Alberta held a referendum and a majority voted “yes,” it would not, on its own, make Alberta independent — it would start a long constitutional process.


⚖️ 3. Constitutional Amendment — Who Must Agree?

There is legal debate on the exact amending formula that would apply, but generally:

  • General amending formula (Section 38): 7 provinces representing at least 50 % of Canada’s population plus both houses of Parliament.
  • Some constitutional scholars argue that secession might require unanimous consent of all provinces and Parliament, because leaving affects the entire federation.

This makes the legal hurdles extremely high.


🧑‍🤝‍🧑 4. Indigenous and Treaty Rights Must Be Addressed

Any negotiation over separation couldn’t ignore the fact that:

  • Most of Alberta lies on treaty territory (Treaties 6, 7, 8) between First Nations and the Crown at the federal level.
  • A province can’t unilaterally “take” treaty land or extinguish treaty obligations.
  • Under both Canadian law and international frameworks (e.g., UNDRIP), negotiation with First Nations and free, prior, and informed consent would be necessary for any legal change affecting treaty rights.

This further complicates and probably lengthens any real separation scenario.


📉 5. Provincial Laws (Like Referendums) Do Not Override the Constitution

Alberta’s recent provincial laws — such as Bill 54 lowering the signature threshold for citizen referendums — can help organize public expression of opinion but cannot change the Constitution or grant a province the legal right to secede on its own.

A provincial referendum could be struck down by courts if it interferes with constitutional obligations (including treaty and Charter rights).


🧠 Summary — What Would Be Required

  1. A provincial referendum on separation with a clear, unambiguous question.
  2. A clear majority “yes” result recognized by the House of Commons under the Clarity Act.
  3. Negotiations between the Government of Canada, Alberta, all other provinces, and Indigenous peoples on terms of separation.
  4. A constitutional amendment formally allowing Alberta to leave, approved per one of Canada’s constitutional amending formulas.
  5. Resolution of federal obligations, division of assets and debts, and recognition of treaty rights.

This is not a quick or simple process — it would likely take many years of negotiation and legal work, and there’s no guaranteed outcome even if a referendum passed.