God is…

1. God is not a being; God is Being itself.

This is the central idea of classical theism, particularly in the tradition of Thomas Aquinas.

Consider the difference:

A tree exists.

A human being exists.

A planet exists.

God is the reason anything exists at all.

The first three are things that possess existence. God, according to classical theism, is not another thing possessing existence. God is the ultimate source of existence.

This is sometimes expressed as the distinction between beings and Being itself.

2. God’s existence is not the same as ours.

When we say that a person exists, we mean that a particular individual is present in reality.

We can distinguish between what that person is (their essence) and the fact that they exist.

Classical theism argues that this distinction does not apply to God. God’s essence and existence are identical.

God doesn’t have existence. God is existence.

This is an important part of Aquinas’s philosophy.

3. God cannot be adequately described through ordinary categories.

This is connected to apophatic theology, sometimes called negative theology.

The idea is that human language and concepts are inadequate to describe God.

We can say what God is not:

God is not a physical object.

God is not limited by space.

God is not one being among other beings.

God is not dependent on anything outside himself.

But when we try to say positively what God is, we encounter the limitations of human language.

A good church provides community, purpose, and opportunity. What a church does not provide is a true knowledge of God. Pastors preach opinions, and opinions change from pastor to pastor. God is mostly unknowable.

The End is Always Near!

The founding motives of a movement are baked into it for its entire lifespan. A movement cannot evolve beyond its original purpose.

Apocalypticism sees world history in the grip of warring forces, God and Satan, the spirits of truth and error, light and darkness … the old age has moved to its allotted end and the age of consummation is at hand, the age of the vindication of the elect and the redemption of the world.

Frank Moore Cross, Ancient Library, pg. 77

Christianity began as an apocalyptic movement. The world as it was known was about to end and be radically transformed by the coming of the Son of Man. The Faith does not make sense without that expectation. The end is always near, or the Church settles into stagnant dogma and tradition. However, the New Testament’s ethical teachings are less a handbook for ordinary moral living than instructions for how to conduct oneself in the last days.

For two thousand years, Christian predictions of the end have been wrong, yet the predictions keep coming. Christianity thrives on apocalypticism; without it, the movement loses its purpose.

The New Testament authors were wrong in their timing. They all expected the end to occur within their own generation. And what end exactly did they anticipate? It appears they awaited the end of Israel’s suffering and the end of the hostile world surrounding the Jewish people. It was a localized end—localized to the world they knew and lived in.

How did Israelite theology reach that point? Early in the Hebrew scriptures Israel worshiped YHWH. YHWH was more powerful than the other gods, and if Israel stayed loyal and obeyed him, he would protect them from their enemies and give them victory in their wars. Yet Israel was conquered, first by Assyria, then by Babylon. How could this be if YHWH is the most powerful? The answer: Israel was being punished by YHWH. He was using these other nations to discipline his own people. He had control over all the nations.

Good. But after the return from exile, after the second temple had been constructed, and after the Jews were living according to the law faithfully, there was still persecution. They remained under the thumb of the Greeks and then the Romans. What of this? God revealed the answer: a cosmic battle was underway. Spiritual forces of good and evil fought in the heavens. The persecution came down from the powers and principalities ruling in the skies.

This is the world into which Christianity was born. Jesus came as the apocalyptic Messiah. He came to radically change the world, restore his people, end death, and establish a good and glorious kingdom.

The problem is that did not happen. There is still death and suffering. If there is a kingdom with Jesus on the throne, it is not clear how that is manifest in our world today. For many Christians, the future hope has been reduced to an unfalsifiable claim about life after death not even found in scripture.

And so the apocalyptic expectation continues. On and on. The end is always near.

The Ten Modes of Aenesidemus: Core Arguments of Pyrrhonian Skepticism

  1. From the variety among animals
    Different species perceive the same objects differently (e.g., what is pleasant or nourishing to one animal is harmful or repulsive to another). We have no privileged reason to prefer human perceptions as the true ones.
  2. From the differences among human beings
    Individual humans (or groups) differ in constitution, temperament, and preferences, producing conflicting impressions of the same things. There is no neutral standard for deciding whose perception is correct.
  3. From the different structures of the sense organs
    The same object appears differently to different senses (e.g., a painting looks three-dimensional to sight but flat to touch). We cannot determine which sense (if any) reveals the object’s true qualities.
  4. From circumstances (or conditions)
    Perceptions vary with the observer’s state: health vs. illness, waking vs. sleeping, youth vs. age, motion vs. rest, hunger, drunkenness, emotional states, etc. The same thing can appear hot, sweet, or beautiful under one condition and the opposite under another.
  5. From positions, distances, and locations
    Objects change appearance according to where and how they are viewed (e.g., a tower looks round from afar and square up close; the same oar looks bent in water and straight out of it).
  6. From intermixtures
    We never perceive objects in isolation; they are always mixed with the medium (air, moisture, etc.) or with our own bodily conditions. What we experience is therefore a compound, not the pure object itself.
  7. From the quantities and compositions (or formations) of objects
    The same substance appears different according to its amount or arrangement (e.g., a few grains of sand feel rough, a larger quantity feels smooth; wine in small amounts invigorates, in large amounts intoxicates).
  8. From relativity
    Everything is relative to the perceiver, the circumstances, or other things. Nothing can be known as it is “in itself,” independently of these relations.
  9. From the frequency or rarity of occurrence
    Rare or unusual things strike us as more remarkable or valuable than common ones, even if they are not intrinsically different. Habit and familiarity alter our impressions.
  10. From customs, laws, beliefs, and dogmatic assumptions
    Different cultures, legal systems, religious traditions, and philosophical schools hold conflicting views about what is good, just, pious, or true. There is no agreed-upon criterion for deciding among them.

I suspend judgment on most claims to ultimate knowledge or inherent meaning, live by practical appearances and chosen commitments, confront the absence of cosmic significance without despair, and continue to treat certain moral distinctions as more than mere preference.